Month: December 2025

Per Stirpes in Florida Estate Planning: The Positive, the Negative, and the Dreadful

When it comes to estate planning, few terms cause more confusion and more unintended consequences than “per stirpes.” While it might sound like legal jargon, understanding how it works can make or break your estate plan. In Florida, this concept plays a central role in distributing inheritances among descendants. However, it must be used carefully and correctly.

Let us break down what per stirpes means, how it is commonly misunderstood, and how to avoid the costly mistakes that often land Florida families in court.

The Positive: It is Quite Simple, If You Use It Correctly

Per stirpes is a Latin phrase that translates to “by branch.” It is a method of distributing an inheritance down the family tree, i.e., first to children, and if a child is deceased, to that child’s own children (the grandchildren).

Key Rule: Use “per stirpes” only when referring to a person’s descendants and not siblings, nieces, nephews, or children as a separate class.

Examples that work:

  • “To my descendants, per stirpes.”
  • “To John Smith’s descendants, per stirpes.”
  • “To my father’s descendants, per stirpes.”

In each of these examples, the term tells us how to divide the inheritance among the descendants of one specific individual. The distribution starts with that person’s children. If one of them has passed away, their share passes down to their children.

This language is standard in Florida Last Wills and Trusts, and, when used properly, it is a reliable and predictable way to keep assets in the family.

The Negative: It is Easy to Get Wrong

Unfortunately, per stirpes is frequently misused in estate documents. That is because people often think of it as a shortcut or catch-all for naming backup beneficiaries. It is not.

Incorrect Example: “To my brothers and sisters, per stirpes.”

This seems simple, but it is legally incorrect. The term per stirpes applies only to a person’s descendants. Your siblings are not your descendants. The correct phrase (if you want your siblings’ children to inherit their share if a sibling dies) might be: “To my mother’s descendants, per stirpes.”

Yes, that sounds a bit more awkward, however, it is legally correct and avoids confusion or disputes. Keep in mind:

  • “Children” are only part of your descendants and not the same as “descendants.”
  • You cannot use per stirpes to divide property among siblings, friends, or any other class of beneficiary.
  • Adding words like “then-living” can introduce ambiguity and should usually be avoided.

The Dreadful: Misuse Can Lead to Family Fights

The worst misuse of per stirpes happens when people try to combine it with other correct sounding but legally inconsistent terms.

Example: “To my children in equal shares, per stirpes.”

This may seem like you are saying: “I want my kids to inherit equally, and if one of them dies, their kids will take their place.” But legally, it may be a mess. You are mixing a class gift (children) with a distribution method (per stirpes) that does not apply to that class. This could trigger costly litigation among your children and grandchildren.

Even worse is writing:

“To my son, James, per stirpes.”

That statement is legally meaningless and confusing. You are making a gift to one person but then trying to divide it among his descendants using per stirpes, which is only used with a class of descendants, not a single named person.

Bottom Line: Keep It Clean and Legally Sound

Here is the golden rule:

Always use “per stirpes” only with the word “descendants,” and always tie it to one person.

If your goal is to make sure your assets pass to your children, and if they are no longer living, to your grandchildren and great-grandchildren, then use:

“To my descendants, per stirpes.” Or, To my beloved child. If my child predeceases me, then per stirpes to his/her lineal descendants. If my child predeceases me leaving no issue, then per stirpes to my lineal descendants.

Do not try to be clever or concise at the cost of clarity. In estate planning, clarity equals protection for your wishes and your loved ones.

The foregoing is a brief and general overview of the topic and the need for specific and experienced legal and tax advice is emphasized.

Questions About Florida Estate Planning?

At CASERTA & SPIRITI in Miami Lakes, we can focus on crafting legally sound, personalized estate plans that reflect your values and protect your family.

Whether you are naming beneficiaries, drafting a Last Will, or creating a Trust, we can help you avoid costly mistakes and ensure your estate plan truly reflects your intentions.

Contact us today to schedule a consultation. Serving Miami-Dade County and clients throughout South Florida.

Living Will vs. Do Not Resuscitate Order in Florida: What is the Real Difference?

When planning for medical emergencies or end-of-life care in Florida, two documents often cause confusion: the Living Will and the Do Not Resuscitate Order (DNRO/DNR). Although people sometimes use these terms interchangeably, they serve very different purposes under Florida law. Understanding the distinction is essential to ensuring your wishes are honored when you are unable to speak for yourself.

As part of a comprehensive incapacity and estate plan, most Floridians should have:

  • A Durable Power of Attorney,
  • A Designation of Health Care Surrogate, and
  • A Living Will.

These advance directives allow your loved ones to manage your legal, financial, and medical decisions without court intervention.

What a Florida Living Will Actually Does

A Living Will is your written statement outlining which life-prolonging procedures you want, or do not want, if you are diagnosed with:

  • A terminal condition,
  • An end-stage condition, or
  • A persistent vegetative state,

as defined in Chapter 765, Florida Statutes.

Life-prolonging procedures can include:

  • Ventilators and breathing machines
  • Feeding tubes
  • Surgery and dialysis
  • Pacemakers or implanted devices
  • CPR and resuscitation efforts
  • Other invasive treatments used solely to prolong the dying process

Most importantly, your Living Will expresses whether you wish to be resuscitated under these circumstances, but it does not create a medical order prohibiting resuscitation. Instead, it tells your physicians and healthcare surrogate what you want and directs them to follow those wishes.

What a Florida Do Not Resuscitate Order (DNRO/DNR) Does

A DNRO (Form DH 1896) is not an advance directive. It is a medical order signed by your physician or APRN (Advanced Practice Registered Nurse) that instructs emergency personnel not to perform CPR if your heart stops or you stop breathing.

Key distinctions:

  • It must be on yellow paper, per Florida Department of Health requirements, so EMS can quickly identify it.
  • It is typically not prepared by your attorney—your doctor must issue it.
  • At home, it should be placed where EMS can easily find it (commonly the refrigerator or bedroom door).
  • Without a DNRO/DNR present and visible, EMS must perform CPR, even if your Living Will states otherwise.

A Living Will expresses your intentions; a DNRO/DNR enforces them in real-time during an emergency.

Why DNROs Matter: The Realities of CPR

Many people do not realize how physically traumatic and medically ineffective CPR can be, especially for the elderly or those with chronic illnesses. CPR can lead to:

  • Broken ribs
  • Internal bleeding
  • Lung punctures
  • Immediate placement on a ventilator

Statistically:

  • A healthy adult has less than a 15% chance of a full recovery after CPR.
  • An older adult with serious illness has less than a 2% chance of meaningful recovery.

For this reason, many Floridians choose a DNRO/DNR to avoid unnecessary suffering when death is expected or inevitable.

What Decisions Does a Living Will Cover?

Without clear instructions, Florida healthcare providers must use every available intervention to sustain life. Your Living Will allows you to decide while competent—whether to accept or decline:

  • Mechanical ventilation
  • Intubation
  • CPR
  • Feeding tubes
  • Dialysis
  • Blood transfusions
  • Antibiotics
  • Other aggressive treatments

These decisions are deeply personal, and Florida law allows you to make them in advance.

Florida’s Legal Framework for Living Wills

Under Florida Statutes Chapter 765:

  • Any competent adult may create a Living Will.
  • It must be signed in front of two witnesses, one of whom is not a spouse or blood relative.
  • It remains valid until you revoke it.
  • Healthcare providers who follow your properly executed Living Will in good faith receive legal protection.

Two Common Approaches to End-of-Life Care Decisions

  1. Maximum Intervention
    Some individuals prefer that all possible medical treatments be used, regardless of prognosis. Their Living Will may state, for example:
    “I direct healthcare providers to use all available life-prolonging procedures, regardless of my condition or likelihood of recovery.”
  2. Comfort-Focused Care
    Others prioritize avoiding unnecessary pain when recovery is not medically possible:
    “If I am in a terminal condition with no reasonable probability of recovery, I direct that life-prolonging procedures be withheld or withdrawn, and that comfort care and pain management be provided.”

Most Florida Living Wills allow you to select specific interventions you would accept or refuse.

Benefits of Creating a Living Will in Florida

A Florida-compliant Living Will offers significant advantages:

  1. Ensures your medical wishes are followed
  2. Reduces emotional burden on your family
  3. Prevents conflict among relatives
  4. Preserves dignity in your final stages of life

Tips for an Effective Florida Living Will

To ensure your Living Will works as intended:

  • Be specific about the treatments you would accept or decline.
  • Update it periodically as circumstances or beliefs change.
  • Discuss your choices with loved ones and your healthcare surrogate.
  • Provide copies to your doctors and keep it accessible.
  • Coordinate it with your Healthcare Surrogate Designation and other directives.

A Difficult but Essential Conversation

Discussing end-of-life care may feel uncomfortable, but documenting your wishes now offers tremendous peace of mind. By completing a valid Florida Living Will and, when appropriate, working with your doctor to execute a DNRO/DNR, you ensure that your values guide your care and that your loved ones are spared from making painful decisions in moments of crisis.

The foregoing is a brief and general overview of the topic and the need for specific and experienced legal and tax advice is emphasized.

If you have any additional questions regarding the foregoing or have any legal issues or concerns, please contact the law firm of CASERTA & SPIRITI in Miami Lakes, Florida.

A Jewish Living Will in Florida: Ensuring Your Medical Care Honors Both State Law and Halacha

For many Jewish individuals and families in Florida, end-of-life planning is not only a legal responsibility but also a deeply personal expression of faith. A Jewish Living Will—often drafted as a Halachic Living Will—allows Floridians to document their medical wishes in a way that is fully compliant with Florida law while ensuring that all healthcare decisions align with Jewish law (Halacha) and the guidance of a trusted rabbinic authority.

This document integrates the requirements of Florida’s advance directive statutes with the religious principles that govern ethical medical decision-making in Judaism, offering clarity, peace of mind, and legal protection for you and your loved ones.

What Is a Jewish (Halachic) Living Will?

A Jewish or Halachic Living Will is a Florida Advance Directive that:

  • Meets all legal requirements for validity under Florida Statutes Chapter 765,
  • Appoints a healthcare surrogate who understands your religious wishes,
  • Instructs medical providers that all decisions must be made in accordance with Halacha,
  • Often designates a rabbi or recognized halachic authority to guide the surrogate and medical team.

This document ensures that your treatment preferences, including life support, pain management, artificial nutrition and hydration, and end-of-life decisions, adhere fully to Jewish religious law.

Key Elements of a Jewish Living Will in Florida

1. Compliance With Florida Legal Requirements

To be valid in Florida, a Living Will, Jewish or otherwise, must be:

  • Signed by the principal (the person creating it),
  • Witnessed by two adults,
  • With at least one witness who is not the principal’s spouse or blood relative.

If the principal cannot physically sign, a witness may sign on their behalf in the principal’s presence and at their direction.

2. Incorporation of Jewish Law (Halacha or Halakha or Halachah)

A Jewish Living Will may include:

  • Direct instructions on life-prolonging treatment and life support,
  • Guidance on pain management consistent with halachic principles,
  • Requests for rabbinic consultation before major medical decisions,
  • Statements regarding artificial hydration, nutrition, and resuscitation consistent with Torah law.

Some individuals choose to specify a particular rabbi or organization whose halachic rulings should be followed.

3. Appointment of a Healthcare Surrogate

Florida law allows you to designate a healthcare surrogate who:

  • Makes medical decisions if you become incapacitated,
  • Ensures your halachic instructions are communicated and honored,
  • Consults with the rabbinic authority identified in the document.

This designation is essential, as medical professionals in Florida rely on the legally appointed surrogate to interpret and enforce your wishes.

4. Use of Clear, Customized Definitions

Florida statutes do not define every medical term relevant to halachic end-of-life issues. A Jewish Living Will should clearly define:

  • Life-prolonging procedures,
  • Artificial hydration and nutrition,
  • Comfort care and palliative treatment,
  • Circumstances that require rabbinic review.

This minimizes ambiguity and helps ensure compliance with both civil and religious expectations.

5. Ensuring Halachic and Legal Consistency

Working with an attorney knowledgeable in both Florida estate planning and religiously compliant Advance Directives ensures:

  • Alignment between Florida law and Jewish ethical mandates,
  • Avoidance of contradictions that could invalidate the document,
  • Proper execution and enforceability in a medical crisis.

Organizations such as Agudath Israel of America, NASCK (National Association of Chevra Kadisha), and the Greater Miami Jewish Federation also provide guidance and forms that reflect widely accepted halachic standards.

A Halachic Living Will: How It Differs From a Standard Living Will

Most standard living will forms require a person to select specific medical preferences for each scenario. A Halachic Living Will takes a different approach.

It typically:

  • Declares that all medical decisions must comply with halacha,
  • Delegates interpretation of Jewish law to a qualified rabbi or authority,
  • Ensures that treatment options are evaluated based on halachic definitions of pikuach nefesh (preservation of life), suffering, and dignity.

This ensures consistent, halachically appropriate decisions even in complex or unforeseen medical situations.

How to Create a Jewish Living Will in Florida

1. Consult the Right Professionals

Discuss your goals with:

  • A Florida estate planning attorney,
  • Your rabbi or halachic advisor,
  • Your physician and family.

This helps ensure clarity and reduces the likelihood of disputes or confusion.

2. Obtain a Halachic Living Will Form

Florida-specific forms and guidance are available from:

  • Agudath Israel of America,
  • National Association of Chevra Kadisha (NASCK),
  • Greater Miami Jewish Federation,
  • Cedars-Sinai and other hospitals with Jewish bioethics programs.

These documents can be adapted to meet Florida’s statutory requirements.

3. Draft the Combined Document

Your attorney will integrate:

  • Florida’s legally required language,
  • Your specific halachic directives,
  • The appointment of a surrogate and rabbinic authority.

4. Execute the Document Properly

Sign your Living Will in the presence of two qualified adult witnesses as required by Florida law.

5. Provide Copies to All Necessary Parties

Distribute copies to:

  • Your healthcare surrogate,
  • Your treating physician(s),
  • Your family members,
  • Your rabbi,
  • Your attorney.

You may also choose to register it with the U.S. Will/Living Will Registry or The U.S. Advance Care Plan Registry (USACPR) for immediate hospital access.

What a Jewish Living Will Is Not

A Jewish (Halachic) Living Will is not the same as a Halachic Will or Last Will (Tzava’ah), which addresses inheritance and distribution of assets according to Jewish law. Many individuals complete both as part of their overall estate plan.

Conclusion

A Jewish or Halachic Living Will gives Florida residents a powerful tool to ensure their medical care reflects both:

  • Florida’s legal requirements, and
  • The timeless ethical principles of Jewish law.

By thoughtfully preparing this document, you protect your dignity, relieve your family of uncertainty, and guarantee that your care is handled in accordance with your faith and your values.

The foregoing is a brief and general overview of the topic and the need for specific and experienced legal and tax advice is emphasized.

If you have any additional questions regarding the foregoing or have any legal issues or concerns, please contact the law firm of CASERTA & SPIRITI in Miami Lakes, Florida.

An Islamic Living Will in Florida: Protecting Your Medical Wishes With Faith-Aligned and Legally Compliant Planning

For Muslim individuals and families in Florida, advance medical planning involves both legal responsibility and religious guidance. An Islamic (Muslim) Living Will allows you to clearly document your medical wishes in a way that complies with Florida law while honoring the ethical and spiritual principles of Sharia (Islamic law). This combined directive helps ensure that your treatment, especially during critical or end-of-life moments, is handled according to Islamic values such as preservation of life (Hifz al-Nafs), human dignity, and the avoidance of unnecessary suffering.

This document is legally recognized in Florida and serves as an essential part of a comprehensive estate and incapacity plan for Muslims across the state.

What Is an Islamic Living Will?

An Islamic Living Will is a Florida advance directive that:

  • Meets Florida’s statutory requirements for a valid Living Will,
  • Outlines your medical treatment preferences under Islamic bioethics,
  • Appoints a healthcare surrogate who understands and will honor your religious beliefs, and
  • Ensures that any decisions made on your behalf reflect your faith and values.

It is important to understand that an Islamic Living Will is separate and distinct from a Last Will and Testament (Wasiyyah), which governs the distribution of assets after death. The Islamic Living Will is purely a medical decision-making document.

Key Legal Requirements for a Valid Living Will in Florida

Under Chapter 765, Florida Statutes, a Living Will must meet certain conditions to be enforceable. A Florida-compliant Islamic Living Will must:

  • ✔ Be executed by a mentally competent adult
    You must be at least 18 years old and of sound mind at the time of signing.
  • ✔ Be signed in the presence of two witnesses
    At least one witness cannot be your spouse or a blood relative.
  • ✔ Be in writing
    Oral directives are not legally valid.
  • ✔ Be provided to your physician or medical facility
    This ensures medical staff know your wishes during a crisis.
  • ✔ Ideally include a Designation of Healthcare Surrogate
    This companion document authorizes the person you trust, preferably someone familiar with Islamic medical ethics, to make decisions if you are incapacitated.
  • ✔ Notarization
    Not required under Florida law but strongly recommended to prevent challenges or claims of improper execution.

Incorporating Islamic Principles Into Your Living Will

Islamic bioethical guidelines strongly influence medical decision-making. An Islamic Living Will may include:

1. Preservation of Life (Hifz al-Nafs)

You may specify that all treatments intended to preserve life should be considered, so long as they offer a reasonable expectation of recovery and are not excessively burdensome.

2. Avoiding Treatment That Only Prolongs the Dying Process

Islam teaches that when death is imminent and no medical intervention will restore meaningful recovery; it is permissible to decline extraordinary or futile treatments.

Your Living Will may direct:

  • No artificial life support where recovery is medically impossible
  • Withdrawal or refusal of life-prolonging procedures when death is inevitable
  • Comfort care only, including pain relief consistent with Islamic teachings

3. Pain Relief and Palliative Care

You can request pain relief even if it may unintentionally hasten death, provided the intent is not to cause death, consistent with Islamic ethics.

4. Organ Donation and Transplants

Different Islamic schools of thought allow organ donation under specific circumstances. Your Living Will can clearly express your position on:

  • Donating organs,
  • Receiving organ transplants,
  • Any religious conditions or restrictions.

5. Islamic Funeral and Burial Instructions

Although funeral directions do not make a Living Will legally binding, many Muslims include statements such as:

  • No embalming or autopsy unless legally required,
  • Timely burial in accordance with Islamic practice,
  • Notification of an Islamic center or imam.

Including these instructions can help guide family members in honoring your religious obligations.

Drafting an Islamic Living Will in Florida

Creating a document that is both legally enforceable and religiously compliant requires careful legal and religious consultation. A well-drafted Islamic Living Will typically involves the following steps:

1. Consult a Florida Estate Planning Attorney

To ensure the document meets all state requirements and aligns with Sharia principles, choose an attorney familiar with:

  • Florida’s advance directive laws,
  • Islamic bioethics and inheritance concepts, and
  • The proper drafting of medical directives for Muslim clients.

2. Clarify Your Religious and Medical Preferences

Discuss your beliefs and intentions regarding:

  • Life support
  • Resuscitation (DNR/DNI preferences, i.e., Do Not Resuscitate and Do Not Intubate)
  • Artificial nutrition and hydration
  • Organ donation
  • Levels of pain management

Your attorney can help translate these preferences into legally enforceable language.

3. Use Reputable Islamic Resources for Guidance

Many Islamic organizations provide worksheets and educational materials, including:

  • Local Masjids and Islamic centers
  • Islamic medical ethics organizations
  • National Sharia-compliant estate planning groups

These tools can help you prepare, but they do not replace a properly drafted legal document.

4. Execute the Document Properly

Sign the Islamic Living Will with two adult witnesses in accordance with Florida law. Consider notarizing the document for added security.

5. Distribute Copies to Key Individuals

Provide copies to:

  • Your healthcare surrogate,
  • Your primary care physician,
  • Your family,
  • Your attorney,
  • Your preferred Islamic center, if desired.

This ensures your wishes are known and honored in an emergency.

Why an Islamic Living Will Matters

Creating an Islamic Living Will provides significant benefits:

  • ✔ Ensures your treatment aligns with your faith
    Medical decisions will reflect Islamic bioethical principles.
  • ✔ Prevents confusion and conflict among loved ones
    Your family will not have to guess or debate your wishes.
  • ✔ Protects your legal rights
    Florida providers must follow a properly executed Living Will.
  • ✔ Provides peace of mind
    You maintain control over your medical care, even if you cannot speak for yourself.

Conclusion

An Islamic Living Will is an essential tool for Muslims in Florida who want to ensure that their medical treatment, especially in critical or end-of-life circumstances, reflects both Florida law and Islamic values. By thoughtfully planning ahead and working with a qualified estate planning attorney, you can safeguard your religious principles, reduce stress for your family, and secure dignified, faith-aligned medical care.

The foregoing is a brief and general overview of the topic and the need for specific and experienced legal and tax advice is emphasized.

If you have any additional questions regarding the foregoing or have any legal issues or concerns, please contact the law firm of CASERTA & SPIRITI in Miami Lakes, Florida.